Of course he would or maybe longer he gets worse every year and now it's cost us two games at least in the ALCS - been saying for at least 2 years he has to go even before Girardi. Too many screwups (that were always blamed on the manager) He doesn't seem to be able to change plans according to what's happening in the game. Just listen to Boone's statements - we didn't wanted Sabathia to pitch to Bradley Jr = totaling ignoring the fact that C was struggling in the first two innings & then hits Benitenti. I might get too emotional which I why I'm not a coach or manager but Rothchild is paid to see these things - time to incorporate the human element with sabermetrics IF WE WANT TO WIN.